Saturday, January 12, 2013

The Tables Are Turned

Since it was released, the photo below, which even got the notice of the New York Times, has been the cause of much controversy.


The Times' account:

WASHINGTON — In an Oval Office meeting on Dec. 29, 11 of President Obama’s top advisers stood before him discussing the heated fiscal negotiations. The 10 visible in aWhite House photo are men. 
In the days since, Mr. Obama has put together a national security team dominated by men, with Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts nominated to succeed Hillary Rodham Clinton as the secretary of state, Chuck Hagel chosen to be the defense secretary and John O. Brennan nominated as the director of the Central Intelligence Agency. Given the leading contenders for other top jobs, including chief of staff and Treasury secretary, Mr. Obama’s inner circle will continue to be dominated by men well into his second term.

And of course since that time, Obama has nominated only men to fill cabinet level positions.  To combat charges of being anti-woman (in other words, a Republican), the White House released the following picture:



I assure you, this story did not come from The Onion.  This is not satire.  The picture above was not doctored.

It's interesting when the tenants of modern liberalism (e.g., egalitarianism run amok a la Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron) come back to bite them.  And from reports I've seen, it looks as though Democrats do have something against women after all.

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Educating Boehner

This WSJ piece by Stephen Moore is very insightful into President Obama's lack of seriousness in tackling the debt problem (which is really a spending problem) in this country.  In it, Moore interviews Speaker John Boehner and some truly appaling details emerge from the so-called "fiscal cliff" back room dealings:

What stunned House Speaker John Boehner more than anything else during his prolonged closed-door budget negotiations with Barack Obama was this revelation: "At one point several weeks ago," Mr. Boehner says, "the president said to me, 'We don't have a spending problem.' "

And:

The president's insistence that Washington doesn't have a spending problem, Mr. Boehner says, is predicated on the belief that massive federal deficits stem from what Mr. Obama called "a health-care problem." Mr. Boehner says that after he recovered from his astonishment—"They blame all of the fiscal woes on our health-care system"—he replied: "Clearly we have a health-care problem, which is about to get worse with ObamaCare. But, Mr. President, we have a very serious spending problem." He repeated this message so often, he says, that toward the end of the negotiations, the president became irritated and said: "I'm getting tired of hearing you say that." 

Obama, the "great compromiser":

Mr. Boehner confirms that at one critical juncture he asked Mr. Obama, after conceding on $800 billion in new taxes, "What am I getting?" and the president replied: "You don't get anything for it. I'm taking that anyway."

Boehner's tone throughout the piece is somewhat naive, e.g., this section:

...Mr. Boehner says he won't engage in any more closed-door budget negotiations with the White House, which are "futile." He adds: "Sure, I will meet with the president if he wants to," but House Republicans will from now on proceed with establishing a budget for the year following what is known as "regular order," and they will insist that Harry Reid and Senate Democrats pass a budget—something they haven't done in nearly four years—before proceeding.

I'm glad he finally figured this out (this is after all a Republic, right?).

This piece shows me that Boehner needs to understand Obama more as Obama understands himself.  He really needs to read Charles Kesler's I Am the Change:  Barack Obama and the Crisis of Modern Liberalism before the next time he negotiates with President Obama.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

The Next Fight

Alana Goodman over at Commentary has some great advice on how Republicans should go about cutting government spending (and yes, that includes defense cuts) in the future:

Fiscal conservatives argue that defense spending shouldn’t be immune from cuts, and they’re right. There is waste and mismanagement within the Pentagon, just like any other government bureaucracy, and there is undoubtedly room for reduction. What’s unacceptable is arbitrary, across-the-board cuts that would force the military to set priorities based on budget reductions, rather than the other way around. Defense should not be dealt with the same way as health care and entitlements; it’s the most important responsibility of the federal government. If there are specific areas where reductions can be made, that should be determined. But choosing a random number and asking the military to cut that much is not the way to do it.

Cuts in defense spending should be based on the circumstances, not simply based on some arbitrary number that means nothing in the real world.

But this whole discussion takes for granted the main problem:  When are these spending cuts ever going to materialize?

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Natural Rights and Religion

I hadn't gotten around to reading Hadley Arkes essay entitled "Is Religious Freedom a 'Natural Right'?" until this weekend.  It truly is a must read.  Arkes main point is that much of how we think about religion and conscience today is a rejection of the natural law based foundations on which the U.S. Constitution was built.  

We often tend to talk about religion in terms of "faith" and "belief," which are merely subjective terms that indicate nothing said in that realm can be proven true or false.  What has been lost is something which George Washington, James Madison, and the Founders understood:  That religion is also based on the claims of reason, or the canons of natural law.  If this is not the case, how then would civil society be able to pass laws banning the practice of suttee, in which an aggrieved widow throws herself on the funeral pyres of her deceased husband?  After all, she is just practicing her religion, right?  Think again:

In contrast, there is the understanding made explicit by John Paul II, that the Church has always moved with two wings, faith and reason. Anyone engaged in the serious study of theology knows how demanding is the discipline of reason that is bound up with the efforts to explore the depths of theology. But beyond that it seems to be one of the best kept secrets in the country—a secret apparently not revealed to many Democratic politicians—that the teaching of the Catholic church on moral questions such as abortion does not depend critically on appeals to faith. The Catholic position on abortion is a weave composed mainly of embryology, the facts of science, and principled reasoning. The Catholic position has been argued in the style of natural law, with reasons that are accessible even to people who are not Catholic. One doesn't have to be Catholic in order to understand the Church's position on abortion, euthanasia, stem cell research, or marriage—and that has been precisely the teaching of the Church: that one doesn't have to be Catholic in order to understand these arguments woven of moral reasoning.

Though Arkes is a Catholic, this reasoning is not simply true just for Catholics.  Case in point, Arkes on what is really going on in the arguments against the provisions in Obamacare that mandate that Catholic hospitals among other religious entities offer contraception coverage in their employees' health plans:

Bishop William Lori pointed out that the Church was not seeking an exemption from the policies on contraception in the way that "conscientious objectors" sought exemptions from service in the military. The Bishop was appealing to "conscience" in the sense once explained with exquisite care by John Paul II in Veritatis Splendor : conscience as an understanding ordered to a body of objective moral truths. John Paul II remarked on that facile tendency to accord to the "individual conscience the status of a supreme tribunal of moral judgment which hands down categorical and infallible decisions about good and evil":

But in this way the inescapable claims of truth disappear, yielding their place to a criterion of sincerity, authenticity and ‘being at peace with oneself', so much so that some have come to adopt a radically subjectivistic conception of moral judgment.  
What is lost then is the recognition that conscience is not directed inward to the self and one's feelings, but outward to the natural law: The "natural law discloses the objective and universal demands of the moral good," and the function of conscience is "the application of the law to a particular case." That seemed to be the understanding at work with Bishop Lori and his colleagues for they were not, as I say, seeking an exemption from the mandate on contraception. They were pronouncing the mandates to constitute an "unjust law, no law at all," and therefore rightly binding on no one. (Italics in original.)

What this means for our understanding of "religion" and how far removed it is (or is not) from what the Founders had in mind:

But just before the drafting of the Constitution, in the "Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments," James Madison had drawn from the Virginia Declaration of Rights as he set forth with a crisp clarity what he and many of the Founders understood by religion: "the duty which we owe to our Creator and the manner of discharging it." Years later, that understanding would be restated by the redoubtable Justice Stephen J. Field in Davis v. Beason (1890), one of the cases dealing with the Mormons. That is probably still the understanding held by most people in this country about the meaning of religion. It is the religion marked by the presence of the God of the Declaration, the God of the logos, of reason, who was understood to have brought forth, as the peak of His creation, those creatures with the capacity to give and understand reasons over matters of right and wrong. There is no understanding of religion more bound up with the deep principles of the American regime and the very ground of the laws. That is not to say that we would be retreating to some notion of "the god of the place," the God associated with thistribe of Americans. The God of the Declaration was not a local god. Serious Protestants, Catholics and Jews understood the God of the Creation as a God with a universal jurisdiction, the Author of moral commands universal in their reach.

But, as Arkes points out, the understanding now dominant in our Courts is one of nihilism, relativism, and atheism.  In an odd irony, judges have deemed that the principle of the rule of law now entails the rejection of the grounding of that principle:  that we no longer have access to the moral principles which used to be thought were available to all.

Please ponder over this essay because the implications drawn from it will be very helpful in continuing the defense of natural rights and natural law against the full implementation of the provisions of Obamacare in the coming years.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Elections Have Consequences and Consequences and Consequences and...

In case you missed this WSJ piece about the crony capitalism taking place behind the scenes -- and months in advance -- of the "fiscal cliff" deal (why isn't when the entitlement programs eventually put the country on ice called the "fiscal cliff" instead?)  read on:

In praising Congress's huge new tax increase, President Obama said Tuesday that "millionaires and billionaires" will finally "pay their fair share." That is, unless you are a Nascar track owner, a wind-energy company or the owners of StarKist Tuna, among many others who managed to get their taxes reduced in Congress's New Year celebration. 
There's plenty to lament about the capital and income tax hikes, but the bill's seedier underside is the $40 billion or so in tax payoffs to every crony capitalist and special pleader with a lobbyist worth his million-dollar salary. Congress and the White House want everyone to ignore this corporate-welfare blowout, so allow us to shine a light on the merriment.

A couple of examples:

Thus Michigan Democrat Debbie Stabenow was able to retain an accelerated tax write-off for owners of Nascar tracks (cost: $78 million) to benefit the paupers who control the Michigan International Speedway. New Mexico's Jeff Bingaman saved a tax credit for companies operating in American Samoa ($62 million), including a StarKist factory. 
Distillers are able to drink to a $222 million rum tax rebate. Perhaps this will help to finance more of those fabulous Bacardi TV ads with all those beautiful rich people. Businesses located on Indian reservations will receive $222 million in accelerated depreciation. And there are breaks for railroads, "New York Liberty Zone" bonds and so much more.

And what these kinds of deals mean:

The costs of all this are far greater than the estimates conjured by the Joint Tax Committee. They include slower economic growth from misallocated capital, lower revenues for the Treasury and thus more pressure to raise rates on everyone, and greater public cynicism that government mainly serves the powerful.

Also, to leave you with something the media did not report:  taxes weren't just raised on the richest Americans.  Social Security payroll taxes were raised by 2%.  But you won't find this out just by browsing the headlines.

Looks like a great deal to me.



Wednesday, January 2, 2013

Jumping Over the Cliff

In lieu of taking time to talk about all the different aspects of the deal that was reached last night to avert the dreaded "fiscal cliff," I will put up a single chart by Yuval Levin that sums it all up.



This is all you need to know about the seriousness of the deal that was just struck between Democrats and Republicans.


Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Revolting

On Saturday I saw Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained and, to be honest, I am still not really sure what to think about it.  The movie revolves around a slave named Django (played by Jamie Foxx) and his quest, with the help of the German bounty Hunter Dr. King Schultz, to rescue his wife from the grips of the evil plantation owner Calvin Candie.  The movie is, as usual for Tarantino, ultra violent (this is probably his most gory movie, which is saying something), but it does have some very entertaining moments.

Samuel L. Jackson, a veteran of Tarantino's movies, plays probably one of the worst characters I've ever seen portrayed in a movie.  His character, Stephen, who is the head slave at Candie's mansion, happily proceeds to help Candie in any endeavor, be it even against the other slaves themselves.  I bring up Jackon's character because of a review of the movie I read in The Boston Globe.  Here is the relevant (and revolting) portion:

[Tarantino] knows what the stakes are and keeps finding clever ways to raise them. They don’t get much higher — or lower, perhaps — than Stephen, the head servant at the Candie mansion. He gets a load of Django, turns defensive, then smells a rat. Samuel L. Jackson plays crusty, waxen Stephen as a vision of depraved loyalty and bombastic jive that cuts right past the obvious association with Uncle Tom. The movie is too modern for what Jackson is doing to be limited to 1853. He’s conjuring the house Negro, yes, but playing him as though he were Clarence Thomas or Alan Keyes or Herman Cain or Michael Steele, men whom some black people find embarrassing.

And I'm sure the reviewer includes himself as part of the group who find those men embarrassing.  It's truly amazing the kind of racial determinism and animus that still exists in parts of this country.  (Nevermind the fact that the people voicing these opinions without irony call themselves "progressive.")